Is Special Education Inclusion Flawed? It Depends on Who You Ask  

A recent article highlights a paper by Douglas Fuchs, a leading special education professor, arguing that the evidence for including students with disabilities in general education classrooms is flawed. Fuchs and his colleagues reviewed over 50 years of research and found that the academic benefits of inclusion are not as clear-cut as previously thought. They suggest that many students with disabilities might benefit more from intensive, specialized instruction in separate settings. 

Fuchs emphasizes that while some students thrive in inclusive settings, the majority may need more targeted support to succeed academically. This perspective challenges the belief that inclusive education is universally beneficial and calls for a reevaluation of how best to educate students with disabilities. 

So, is special education inclusion flawed? It depends on who you ask.  

According to the National Center for Education Statistics, the number of students ages 3-21 who received special education and/or related services under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) in 2022-23 was 7.5 million. We know that the needs of students who require special education vary widely and that no students are the same. While inclusive education has the potential to benefit both students from both the special education population as well as the typical population, there are instances where specialized instruction is warranted for those children needing instruction that addresses their unique challenges and provides the therapies most appropriate to their diagnosis.  

The Elizabeth Lee Black School at the Barber National Institute offers a range of educational program choices designed to help all children achieve their greatest potential.  Our school is specially designed to provide a highly structured classroom environment which allows children with significant disabilities to develop to their fullest. Each day the children participate in educational activities presented within a very predictable routine to confidently practice new skills. Each student’s IEP directs their learning experiences, which integrate a variety of activities throughout the school day, to address their academic, behavioral and therapeutic needs. We pride ourselves on providing innovative services that engage students, help them build confidence, develop future-ready skills, and create avenues for long-term success.  

Fuchs’ research helps us take into consideration that while inclusive education can certainly be beneficial, it might not be the right option for every student.  

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Impacting Lives One Child at A Time: The Key Ingredients for Success 

Being successful comes down to several factors, including people, resources, and a clear goal of doing the very best for the good of those served. 

At the Elizabeth Lee Black School, we have never been content to stand still. We hold a steadfast belief: if a child cannot learn the way we teach, we must teach the way a child learns.   

It is our exceptional staff, enduring partnerships, innovative services, and state-of-the-art technology that drive this mission forward. Together, we are changing lives, one child at a time. 

Inspired by the legacy of Dr. Gertrude A. Barber, we continuously reinvent ourselves to meet the evolving needs of our students and their families. 

We are agents of change, and our mission of making dreams come true is unwavering. 

Join me in revisiting the impact we’ve had in 2024 and looking forward to continued growth in 2025. 

Key Ingredient #1: Our Exceptional Staff 

Our success is driven by our dedicated staff, who bring a wealth of knowledge, skills, and diverse perspectives to help our students reach their full potential.  

In addition to offering a comprehensive Approved Private School that serves the needs of 26 school districts in our region, the Barber National Institute offers offsite classrooms at two school districts as well as a Happy Hearts Child Care program and Pre-K Counts programs in both Erie and Corry. I’m convinced we have the highest-caliber staff in the country! The success of our students goes to show the incredible work our staff do every single day. 

Key Ingredient #2: Strong Collaborations 

By leveraging longstanding collaborations, we amplify our impact, accelerate progress, and work tirelessly to make dreams come true for every student. 

In 2024, we collaborated with many groups, including:  

  • 26 School Districts 
  • Edith L. Trees Charitable Trust  
  • Erie Arts & Culture 
  • Erie Insurance 
  • LECOM School of Dentistry 
  • PNC Grow Up Great   
  • Tri-County Intermediate Unit 5 
  • Donors   
  • Countless Volunteers 

And the list goes on 

Key Ingredient #3: An Innovative Strategy  

Our cutting-edge services transform student lives, fostering growth and development beyond the classroom. We break down barriers to engage students, enhancing their readiness for life’s challenges and paving the way for their long-term success. 

In 2024, students benefitted from the following services: 

  • Adaptive playground equipment 
  • Dog therapy program 
  • Outdoor classrooms 
  • Fitness room 
  • Physical, occupational, & speech therapy 
  • Newly renovated library & sensory room 
  • Adaptive art, physical education, & music classes  
  • Integrated technology in every classroom 
  • Transition planning 

Key Ingredient #4: Embracing Technology  

As technology evolves, we adapt by incorporating state-of-the-art tools, which provide students with real-world experiences.  

These tools help improve communication, enhance students’ learning, drive discovery and wonder, and help develop future-ready skills.   

Tech Quick Facts:  

  • 112 iPads are used in classrooms throughout the school.  
  • The Lü Interactive Playground is used within 100% of physical education classes to make lessons fun and engaging. 
  • Students have access to 3 ActiveFloor units and 8 VR headsets for immersive learning.  
  • Top Skills Gained Through Technology: Cognitive growth, emotional regulation, gross motor skills, independence, self-motivation. 

 What’s next? 

Staff will continue to empower our students and families.  

Collaborations will grow even stronger.  

Innovative services will enhance engagement.  

Technology will help connect more students to the world around them.  

Together, we’ll continue to change lives one child at a time.  

The possibilities are endless in 2025.   

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

The Autism CARES Act of 2024: Empowering Lives, Strengthening Communities

The Autism CARES Act of 2024 passed mid-December and is yet one more step in improving the lives of children and adults with autism spectrum disorder, or ASD.   

I am especially pleased because it emphasizes support across the life span from early intervention services for young children to programs addressing the needs of adults.  Yes, we need to expand our efforts to identify children at an earlier age so that they can begin receiving services. But we are all too familiar with the challenges faced by persons with autism when they exit the educational system at 22 years. This act provides more resources for job training, independent living, and community integration.  The Act also provides funding for healthcare providers, educators, and service workers to receive training to better meet the needs of persons with ASD.  There is also an emphasis on families having increased access to resources that will better enable them to care for their child with ASD.  On a national level, there will be additional funding for research for universities and institutions to study Autism and continue to identify the best practices for the most effective intervention. 

A Closer Look at the Autism CARES Act of 2024:  

Increased funding: The act allocates over $1.95 billion to support autism research, services, and training.  

Comprehensive support: the act provides support across the lifespan, from early intervention services for young children to programs addressing the needs of adults with ASD. The act addresses gaps in services that may currently exist, helping young children with ASD receive timely diagnoses and appropriate therapies while providing more resources for job training, independent living programs, and community integration for adults with ASD.  

Research and training: The act allocates funding for research to enhance our understanding of autism and to improve interventions and treatments across an individual’s lifespan. Additionally, it emphasizes the importance of training for local healthcare providers, educators, and service workers. 

I am hopeful that we can advocate to assure that funding comes to the local level to accomplish all purposes noted above. 

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Honoring Our Champions: The Supporters Who Made 2024 Extraordinary 

As we approach the end of 2024, I want to take this opportunity to recognize our many supporters who are dedicated to fostering positive change within our community.

The Strengthening Foundations home renovation campaign aims to enhance the safety, accessibility, and comfort of the Barber National Institute’s 93 community group homes. The funds raised will be used to remodel kitchens, replace carpeting, update roofs, renovate bathrooms, and add ramps. These essential updates will ensure the best functionality and accessibility for those we serve.

Over the years, the Barber National Institute has garnered countless supporters. In addition to raising critical funds for life-changing programs for our adults and children, our annual fundraisers also serve as invaluable friend-raising events.

The last two months of the year featured two highly successful events, thanks to overwhelming community support.

The 2024 Annual Ladies Only Luncheon was held at the Kahkwa Club on Saturday, November 23. We welcomed 375 women who enjoyed a delicious meal prepared by Chef Chris Cassel and his culinary team, and heard inspiring stories of how the Barber National Institute is making dreams come true for many children and their families. The event also featured a much-anticipated raffle with over 40 gorgeous gift baskets, premier gifts from the Cork 1794 and the Kahkwa Club, and a Brahmin Finley carryall satchel, makeup bag, and designer scarf, all generously donated by our supporters.

We celebrated the 60th Anniversary, A Diamond Christmas Ball, on Saturday, December 14 at the Bayfront Convention Center. Thanks to the efforts of our chair couple, Patrick Barber and his wife Courtney, a record crowd of over 1,200 attended this sold-out event. The funds raised will support our Strengthening Foundations Home Renovation campaign.

Additionally, many friends donated Christmas gifts and food baskets for families in need throughout Erie County.

Thank you to everyone who supports our mission of “making dreams come true!”

Merry Christmas!

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Happy Hearts Child Care Makes a Real Difference for Young Children  

Happy Hearts Child Care began in the 1980s as a neighborhood nursery, aimed at providing quality childcare for our staff to encourage their return to work. This initiative was ahead of its time, predating the concepts of workplace childcare. 

Fast forward 40 years, and Happy Hearts continues to deliver the highest quality childcare for both staff and community children.  We also have a Keystone STAR 4 designation.    

What is Keystone STARS? 

The Pennsylvania Office of Child Development and Early Learning (OCDEL) oversees the Keystone STARS program. STARS stands for Standards, Training/Professional Development, Assistance, Resources, and Supports. A STAR 4 program represents the highest quality of excellence. It meets standards in 4 areas: staff education, learning environment, leadership/management and family and community partnerships. The STARS program is a whole child approach to education and is essential to meeting the holistic and individual needs of each and every child and family. 

So, why should parents choose Happy Hearts for their children?  

From a parent/guardian standpoint, choosing the Happy Hearts Star 4 program at the Barber National Institute ensures that children between the ages of 3 and 5 achieve success when they enter kindergarten. Our Keystone STAR 4 facility ensures our program and staff sustain our STAR 4 during yearly renewals and designations. Staff utilize a curriculum approved by the Office of Child Development and Early Learning (OCDEL) and developmental assessments throughout the year. In addition to supporting a child’s ongoing learning and development, program staff support every family’s well-being. We collaborate with families if there is a concern regarding a child’s growth and development by taking an active listening role, respecting family’s feelings and providing resources and referrals when necessary. We support the success of every child while maintaining a high-quality learning environment with the highly qualified and trained staff.   

Visit https://www.barberinstitute.org/children/early-childhood/happy-hearts-inclusive-preschool for more information. You can also contact Stephanie Robertson, Director of Happy Hearts Child Care, at 814-878-4080.  

From left, Chelsea Spiegel, assistant group supervisor; Stephanie Robertson, director of Happy Hearts Child Care; Alyse Wienecke, group supervisor.  

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Celebrating Ryan’s Achievements on His Birthday  

Birthdays are more than just a celebration of the day we were born; they hold significant importance in our lives for various reasons. They serve as milestones, opportunities for reflection, and moments of joy and connection with loved ones. 

We are celebrating Ryan’s 31st birthday this week, and it’s a good reminder of his growth, achievements, and the experiences we’ve accumulated over the past year. Each year gives me a chance to appreciate Ryan’s journey and help him celebrate how far he’s come while setting new goals for the year ahead. 

I still remember it like it was yesterday… We were living in North East and, of course, we were amid a snowstorm (very similar to the weather we’re experiencing this year!)  

I recall turning up the heat to make sure that his bedroom was warm.  My brother, Joe, who lived next door came by and said that the house felt like a steam room. I turned the heat down, needless to say! 

Jeanne and Dianne came out to assist with his first bath. Dianne, the oldest in her family of 12, had lots of experience with bathing babies.  So, I asked her to help – everything was so new to me! We even did a video of “Ryan’s first bath” which I still have today. 

In the blink of an eye, the next 30 years have passed. There have been peaks and valleys in this journey, but I am truly proud of Ryan’s many successes. He has had a GREAT 2024! 

Between working at Bello’s and BNI, exercising at Planet Fitness, swimming at the Y, skiing at the Peek  in the winters and golfing at Kahkwa in the summers, I am trying, usually unsuccessfully, to keep up with him! 

Ryan’s most favorite “preferred” activity is reading to our Happy Hearts preschool children.  He will tell you that he is a teacher because he” reads to the kids” and “cleans their classrooms.”  Those are his 2 jobs and with Bello’s he has 3.  He firmly believes that he does not need more! He will also tell you “Mom and I are not retiring. We are planning on working at the Barber Center until we are 90 and then we will work at the Center in heaven, and he will read to the kids there.” 

As I look back over the years, I know that I have so much to be grateful for: family, friends, outstanding staff, and the Erie community that welcomes children and adults with disabilities.  

I’m so glad that I have the pleasure, on a daily basis, of seeing Ryan achieve his dreams, just as Dr. Barber would have wanted.  

Happy Birthday Ryan! 

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Let Gratitude and Respect Shine This November  

I wanted to share a few thoughts as we approach Thanksgiving as to how gratitude and respect can and should be shared all year long in the classroom. 

Gratitude and respect are fundamental values that foster a positive and productive learning environment. These values can be experienced from an early age in the classroom. By cultivating gratitude and respect in the classroom, educators can create a supportive atmosphere that encourages collaboration, empathy, and personal growth. 

To effectively integrate gratitude and respect into classroom activities, we can implement some of the following strategies: 

Create a Gratitude List: Invite students to make a list of people they are grateful for. This activity encourages them to reflect on their relationships and recognize the positive influences in their lives. It can be done as a class discussion or as an individual assignment, allowing students to share their thoughts and insights. 

Reflect on Impact: Encourage students to reflect on how these individuals have made a difference in their lives. This reflection can take the form of a written assignment or a group discussion. This process deepens their understanding of gratitude and its significance. 

Record a Heartfelt Video: Have students create a video expressing their gratitude to the individuals they have identified. This activity not only allows them to articulate their feelings but also helps develop their communication skills. The video can be simple, focusing on genuine expressions of thanks and the impact the person has had on their lives. 

Share the Video: Finally, encourage students to share their videos with the individuals they are honoring. This act of sharing spreads joy and reinforces the importance of gratitude. It also strengthens the bonds between students and their support networks, fostering a culture of appreciation and respect. 

Can you think of other activities?  

Incorporating gratitude and respect into the classroom is essential for creating a nurturing and effective learning environment. By engaging students in activities that promote these values, educators can help them develop important social and emotional skills.  

Through these practices, students learn to appreciate the contributions of others and recognize the value of kindness. Setting the foundation for a more compassionate and respectful society starts in the classroom!  

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Kindness in Action: Fun Ways to Celebrate! 

Celebrate National Kindness Day on November 13th with Fun and Meaningful Activities!

Children can engage in a variety of enjoyable and impactful ways to honor National Kindness Day. Here are some creative ideas: 

Kindness Wordsearch: Kick off the day with a Kindness Wordsearch. This activity not only enhances vocabulary and spelling skills but also introduces students to words that embody kindness. 

Collaborative Coloring Activity: Organize a Kindness Collaborative Coloring Poster where students can contribute their artistic flair while promoting teamwork and creativity. 

Notes of Kindness: Encourage students to write heartfelt notes to their classmates, teachers, and school staff, spreading positivity and appreciation throughout the school. 

Kindness Writing Challenge: Create a list of simple acts of kindness for students to complete throughout the day or week. Ideas could include holding the door for someone, sharing supplies, or assisting a friend with their work. 

Reading Stories About Kindness: Share inspiring books that highlight kindness and empathy, such as Have You Filled a Bucket Today? by Carol McCloud, Kindness Is My Superpower by Alicia Ortego, and Those Shoes by Maribeth Boelts. 

Kindness Jar: Set up a Kindness Jar in the classroom. Provide slips of paper for students to jot down acts of kindness they observe. Take time to read and celebrate these moments together as a class. 

These activities not only make the day memorable but also help instill the values of kindness and empathy in students, creating a lasting impact on their hearts and minds. 

Let’s spread the message of Kindness Day not only on November 13 but throughout the year! 

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Tips for A Not-So-Spooky Halloween 

Dressing up as a favorite superhero, trick-or-treating for goodies, and spending the evening with friends are just a few reasons why Halloween can be such a fun holiday for parents and children alike. However, for many children with autism this night also has the potential to be a difficult and stressful time of year.  

If you or someone you know has a child with special needs but still plans to trick-or-treat, here are some ideas to make sure everyone has a safe and fun Halloween. Many of them I implemented when Ryan was a trick or treater, and they really worked.   

– Practice: Try on the costume, including make up or masks, to make sure he/she is comfortable; walk the route you intend to take; and talk about what will happen after trick-or-treating. Predictability is key to helping children with autism feel safe and calm.  

– Role play: Similar to practicing, role playing provides structure and outlines specific behavior for trick-or-treating. Halloween is also a great opportunity to reinforce good manners, such as waiting their turn to ring the doorbell, saying “Trick or Treat,” only taking one treat, and always saying “thank you” before leaving.  

– Be aware of sensory triggers: Although Halloween decorations can be very entertaining, flashing lights or loud sounds may evoke unpleasant sensory reactions for your child.  

– Flashlights: Ryan carried one to help him see in the dark/dim evening. It gave him a sense of comfort and some means of control.  

– Know your limits: As soon as you see your child becoming over-stimulated or agitated, it’s time to go home.  It’s okay to end the evening earlier than planned.  

– Pass Out Candy: This can be a fun alternative for the child who might find it too stressful to go door to door.   

Over the years, Ryan was most successful when we went to the homes of our friends, he felt comfortable but still could “show off” his costume.  Always ask yourself, will my child truly enjoy this, or will I?  Let that answer be your guide in what you choose to do and not do this Halloween. 

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Celebrating Our Incredible Physical Therapists   

National Physical Therapy Month is celebrated each October, and I would like to highlight our two incredible physical therapists Barb Gleason and Chris Gross who provide the very best hands-on physical therapy and a wide range of resources to our children and their families throughout the year.  Physical therapy provides our students with so many benefits, including improved mobility and movement, critical muscle strengthening, and the ability to experience exciting activities such as riding an adaptive bike. 

I’ve asked our four amazing PTs about the impact of their work and the value of the PT profession.   

Barb Gleason 

A great day would involve a sunny day where I could work with my students outside in the fresh air, with lots of cooperation and progress towards what we have been working on.  Seeing the progress our students make, not just mobility wise, but also academically, socially and with their communication truly warms my heart and brings a smile to my face.  A great day also includes good conversation with colleagues and minimal time spent at the computer, which is a non-preferred activity for me.  LOL – I am happiest when I don’t have to sit too long. 

A challenging day would involve multiple interruptions to my schedule, wheelchair and equipment issues and lots of computer time.   

I have been a PT for many years, and I find it wonderful the amount of autonomy and respect the field has gained.  In the early days, we would get prescriptions from doctors that would instruct us on exactly what we were to do with our patients and that over time gave way to “evaluate and treat” scripts. Now with direct access, in most cases you can treat a patient without a physician’s referral.   

In reference to what I would say to a young person interested in PT, I would first ask them if they were “a people person”?  To be an effective PT you need to enjoy being around others and you need to be a good communicator.   You also need to like always being on the move, this is not a sedentary occupation. 

One of the greatest aspects of this field is the opportunity to work in multiple and varied settings.  Yet you can also specialize in area or population if you wish. I have worked in many different settings as a therapist and have found each to have their own unique challenges as well as rewards.  Ultimately, I love being able to help others overcome challenges and be the best they can be, and that is what a PT does regardless of the setting in which they practice. 

Chris Gross 

I think a great day is when I have students on my schedule who enjoy coming to therapy and who put forth their best effort.  PT is a lot more fun when working with students who participate well, regardless of their physical capabilities.  I had a student this school year who thanked me for working with her – that totally melted my heart! 

The most challenging sessions involve setting up the environment so that the student will participate, and we can get something accomplished during a session (kind of the opposite of the previous answer). 

In my opinion, the biggest changes would not be in the PT field itself but in the equipment that we use to support our practice. Improvements in technology and equipment design have allowed PT to use these devices to help people with various disabilities more readily access their environment for improved quality of life. 

There are many practice settings for physical therapists so the answer to that question would depend on the setting in which one is looking to work.  Delivery of PT in the school setting is not like any other PT setting.  We function in more of a support role-but if you enjoy working with kids who have physical challenges and would like to help them succeed in their educational environment, this may be something to consider. 

We are so fortunate to have both Barb and Chris part of our BNI family! 

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment